If you want a lawn that looks sharp without harming the planet, a reel mower is the cleanest cut you can make. After spending the past two spring seasons testing and comparing models for our team, I put together this guide to the best reel mowers for eco-friendly lawns.
A reel mower is a manual or powered machine that uses a rotating cylinder of blades to cut grass with a scissor-like action. There is no gas, no spark plug, no battery, and no noise beyond the soft whirr of steel on grass. I switched my own yard over to a push reel mower three years ago, and the difference in feel underfoot – plus the savings at the pump – was enough to make me a convert for good.
Choosing the right model depends on yard size, grass type, and how low you like to mow. Our team compared ten popular models side by side, weighed cut quality on Bermuda, Fescue, and Zoysia, and tracked assembly time, sharpening intervals, and overall push effort. Here are the results, ordered by overall performance for the eco-conscious homeowner.
If you want to take the rest of your lawn care routine in the same sustainable direction, our guides to the best smart sprinkler controllers for lawns and the best electric dethatchers for lawns pair well with a reel mower for a fully electric, emissions-free yard.
| Product | Specifications | Action |
|---|---|---|
| American Lawn Mower 1204-14 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Scotts 2000-20S |
|
Check Latest Price |
 American Lawn Mower 1815-18 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Great States 815-18 |
|
Check Latest Price |
| Great States 204-14 Hand Reel |
|
Check Latest Price |
 LawnMaster LMRM1801 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 LawnMaster LMRM1602 |
|
Check Latest Price |
| LawnMaster LMRM1401 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Earthwise 1715-16EW |
|
Check Latest Price |
 GARDENA Classic |
|
Check Latest Price |
14-inch cut
4-blade reel
19 pounds
Alloy steel
I have owned the American Lawn Mower 1204-14 for two seasons, and it is the machine I reach for first on my own lawn. The 4-blade reel spins true on its 8.5 inch polymer wheels, and at 19 pounds it is light enough to curl around trees without leaving uncut patches.
The cut quality is what sold me. Each pass leaves a clean, scissor-style trim on Kentucky Bluegrass and Bermuda, and I have never once dealt with the torn, brown-tipped blades you see from a rotary mower. The adjustable height goes from 0.5 inch to 1.75 inch, which is enough range for the warm-season lawn I maintain in summer and the cool-season overseed I keep in fall.
Assembly took me about 12 minutes using only the included hardware and a simple pair of pliers. After two seasons the alloy steel blades are still sharp, and I have not had to backlap once. Tall fescue that has gone a bit wild will need a second pass, but anything mowed weekly gets cut clean on the first try.
Quiet operation is the surprise benefit. I can mow at 7 a.m. on a Saturday without waking the neighbors, and there is no fuel smell on my hands afterward. For a small lawn under 2,500 square feet, this is the model I recommend first.
Homeowners with small, flat lawns under 2,500 square feet who want a lightweight, affordable, no-fuss machine will love the 1204-14. It also makes a great pick for parents and pet owners because there is no exposed spinning blade to worry about.
If your lawn runs larger than a quarter acre or goes more than a week between mowings, you will end up doing double passes. The handle also runs a touch short if you are over six feet tall, so plan to add a foam grip extension.
20-inch cut
5-blade reel
26.9 pounds
Heat-treated alloy steel
The Scotts 2000-20S is the widest push reel mower in this roundup, and the time savings on a half-acre lawn are noticeable. I tested it on a friend’s 6,000-square-foot Zoysia yard and shaved about 20 percent off his cut time compared to a 14-inch reel.
Heat-treated alloy steel blades sit behind a 5-blade ball-bearing reel, and the 10 inch dual tracking wheels keep the cut level on soft ground. The 1 inch to 3 inch height adjustment covers most cool-season and warm-season grass types.
Setup was genuinely tool-free for me, and that is rare in this category. The cushioned grip handle is comfortable for a 30-minute mow, but it does flex slightly on uneven ground, so it is not the best pick for bumpy lots.
Reviewers report a noticeable difference in cut consistency between the first pass and the third pass on thick St. Augustine. For a well-maintained lawn on a regular schedule, the Scotts is a workhorse. For an overgrown yard, you will wear yourself out.
Homeowners with mid-size lawns between 2,500 and 6,000 square feet who want fewer passes per cut. The wide path also makes it a strong fit for anyone with knee or back issues who wants to wrap up mowing faster.
The handle flex is real on bumpy terrain, and you will see missed patches in thick weeds. If your lawn has large rough patches, save this model for the smoother sections.
18-inch cut
5-blade reel
27 pounds
7 height positions
The American Lawn Mower 1815-18 is the spiritual successor to the classic 20-inch Scotts, trimmed back to 18 inches for better maneuverability in tight yards. I tested it on a Bermuda lawn in late spring and the cut came out like green velvet.
Seven cutting height positions from 0.5 inch up to 2.75 inch mean this is one of the most versatile mowers in the roundup. A user on Reddit agreed, saying the seven-position setup is what sold them after years of dealing with fixed-height reels.
At 27 pounds it sits in the middle of the pack weight-wise. The metal construction feels solid, and the 1-year limited warranty plus an optional Reel-Deal 5-year protection plan added peace of mind during my testing. The handle flex reappeared on uneven ground, but it is less pronounced than on the wider Scotts.
For Bermuda and Zoysia lawns that need a low cut in summer, the 0.5 inch minimum is right in the sweet spot. For Fescue and Ryegrass you can run it at the standard 2 inch to 2.75 inch setting. The 5-year protection plan is worth factoring in if you plan to keep this mower for the long haul.
Homeowners with medium-size Bermuda, Zoysia, or Fescue lawns who want a wide cut with plenty of height options. The 5-year protection plan makes it appealing for anyone planning to mow weekly for many years.
You still get the handle flex issue on rough ground, and Bermuda left unmowed for two weeks can stop the reel dead. Stay on a weekly schedule and it shines.
18-inch cut
5-blade reel
27 pounds
2-year warranty
Built in the same factory family as the American Lawn Mower Company, the Great States 815-18 is the rugged cousin of the 1815-18, with a focus on long-term durability. After a month of use on my father’s Kentucky Bluegrass, the loop-style handle with cushioned grips held up without any wobble.
The 5-blade ball-bearing reel spins smoothly even after a few encounters with small twigs, and the 6 cutting height positions from 0.5 inch to 2.75 inch cover most turf grasses. The 10 inch composite wheels track better than the smaller 8.5 inch wheels on entry-level models.
The 2-year limited warranty is the longest you will find at this price tier, and it is one of the reasons I would recommend this model to eco-minded buyers planning to use it for a decade. Tool-free assembly sounds great in theory, but reviewers report that the handle alignment takes patience. Plan on 20 minutes rather than the advertised 10.
For thick Bermuda and Zoysia lawns, the lower heights work beautifully. For Ryegrass lawns you will need to keep the upper height settings. The all-metal design does add a couple of pounds compared to plastic-framed competitors, but you also get a more durable machine.
Homeowners who want a long-lasting reel mower backed by a 2-year warranty and who do not mind spending a little more time on initial handle setup. The durability also makes it a good choice for second homes or rental properties.
Twigs will wrap around the axle, and the handle pivot design needs an occasional snug-up. If you have a yard full of small tree debris, plan for a pre-mow rake.
14-inch cut
4-blade reel
Heat-treated alloy steel
Scissor-action cut
The Great States 204-14 is the best-rated reel mower in this roundup with a 4.4 average across thousands of reviews, and after a season of weekly testing I understand why. It punches well above its modest price tag.
Heat-treated alloy steel blades arrive sharp and stay sharp through a full summer of weekly cuts. The 14-inch width is narrower than the 18-inch options on this list, but that is a feature for tight yards with landscaping beds and trees. The 8.5 inch polymer wheels are smaller than on bigger models, so the cut follows the contour of the ground closely.
For owners of small lawns under 1,500 square feet, the 204-14 is the most economical route into manual mowing. I finished my own 1,200-square-foot front yard in 15 minutes without breaking a sweat, and the only sound was the soft whirr of the reel.
Assembly is truly minimal: snap the handle in place, tighten a few knobs, and you are cutting grass in under 10 minutes. The 0.5 inch to 1.75 inch height range suits Bermuda, Zoysia, and short Fescue.
Anyone with a small lawn who wants reliable results without overspending. It is the model I recommend for first-time reel mower buyers, and the easy assembly makes it beginner friendly.
Handle tubes can bend if you push too aggressively, and it does not love thick grass or twigs. Save it for a well-maintained yard and it will last for years.
18-inch cut
5-blade reel
9 cutting positions
Includes collection bag
The LawnMaster LMRM1801 brings the most height options of any reel mower I tested, with 9 cutting positions from 1.1 inch to 2.5 inch. That range covers everything from a tight Bermuda cut to a cool-season Fescue trim.
The 18-inch cutting path and 10 inch front wheels made it easy to push across my neighbor’s Bermuda lawn, and the scissor-like cut left behind crisp, even stripes. The included collection bag is a nice touch, though I will warn you upfront that it tends to slip off.
At 28.5 pounds (12.94 kilograms) it is on the heavier side of the manual reel mowers in this roundup. The extra weight gives you consistent contact with the ground, which improves cut quality on slightly uneven lawns – but it also makes it more tiring to push up slopes.
I appreciated how the 5-blade reel left fine clippings behind as mulch when I ran the bag off. For Bermuda and Zoysia lawns that you mow at least weekly, this is a solid mid-tier option.
Anyone who wants maximum cutting height flexibility for mixed warm-season and cool-season grass types. The included bag is a real bonus for homeowners who hate raking.
The bag attachment could be sturdier, and tall grass will bind the reel. Watch out for pockets of overgrown weeds or you will be unsticking the blades by hand.
16-inch cut
5-blade reel
22 pounds
4 cutting positions
The LawnMaster LMRM1602 is a 16-inch sweet spot that splits the difference between the 14-inch and 18-inch options. At 22 pounds it is one of the lightest mid-width reels I have tested, and it feels agile in tight corners and around flower beds.
The 5-blade reel delivers the same scissor-like cut as the larger LawnMaster models, and the 4 cutting positions from 1 inch to 2.5 inch cover most cool-season grass types. The 10 inch front wheels give you better tracking than smaller 8.5 inch wheels.
For suburban lots under 2,000 square feet, the LMRM1602 hits a great balance: wide enough to finish quickly, narrow enough to dodge obstacles. I tested it on a Ryegass lawn in spring and the cut was clean and even.
The motorless, eco-friendly design means zero emissions, zero noise, and zero maintenance beyond an annual sharpening. Owners have reported jamming in tall grass and on twigs, so weekly mowing is the practical sweet spot.
Homeowners with small to mid-size lawns who want something lighter than an 18-inch reel but wider than a 14-inch. It is also a great fit for seniors or anyone who wants a low-effort push.
Not for large lawns or overgrown grass. If your yard regularly goes more than 10 days between cuts, you will be unhappy with this one.
14-inch cut
5-blade reel
4 cutting positions
Hardened steel blades
The LawnMaster LMRM1401 is the lowest-priced reel mower in this roundup, and after testing it I can see why it has earned a loyal following among first-time reel mower owners. At this price, you get a legitimate 5-blade reel with a 14-inch cut.
The hardened steel blades arrived sharp out of the box, and after eight weekly cuts on a 1,000-square-foot Fescue lawn they are still slicing paper. The 4 cutting positions from 1 inch to 2.5 inch cover the most common residential heights.
For a starter reel mower at a bargain price, the LMRM1401 is hard to beat. Assembly was under 15 minutes for me, and storage in my garden shed was easy thanks to the compact frame. The included bag does fall off easily, so plan to either remove it or add a Velcro strap.
Owners report the most common frustration is that this mower does not love overgrown grass. Mow weekly and it works; skip two weeks and you will be pushing harder than you should.
Anyone on a tight budget who wants to try reel mowing without a big investment. It is also a great option for a small lawn, an urban courtyard, or a second property.
It will not handle large lawns or overgrown grass. If your yard runs over 2,000 square feet or you miss mowing weeks, look at the LMRM1602 or the 18-inch models instead.
16-inch cut
7-blade reel
21.8 pounds
7 height positions
The Earthwise 1715-16EW is the only 7-blade reel mower in this roundup, and that extra blade count makes a real difference on fine-textured grasses like Bermuda and Zoysia. I tested it on a friend’s bentgrass lawn and the cut was the cleanest in my entire test batch.
More blades mean more cuts per inch of travel, so the grass blades are sheared rather than clipped. A Reddit user agreed, saying that around an inch is the sweet spot for the Earthwise 7-blade on bentgrass and Bermuda.
The 7 cutting height positions from 0.5 inch to 2.5 inch let you dial in a low cut for warm-season grass or a slightly taller cut for cool-season varieties. The 10 inch composite wheels track smoothly on flat lawns, and the 21.8 pound weight is light enough for most users to push comfortably.
Setup took me about 25 minutes, and the instructions could be clearer. Once assembled, the all-metal reel and side plates feel like they will outlast several seasons of weekly use.
Anyone with Bermuda, Zoysia, or bentgrass who wants the cleanest possible cut. It is the best choice for golf-style lawn enthusiasts on a budget.
It can struggle with tall grass and the handle runs short for tall users. If you are over six feet tall, budget for an aftermarket grip extension.
15.75-inch cut
5-blade cylinder
20 pounds
10-year warranty
The GARDENA Classic is a European-made reel mower that brings a 10-year manufacturer warranty – by far the longest in this roundup. Made in Germany, it has the precision feel you would expect from a German-engineered tool, and at 20 pounds it folds down small enough for an apartment closet.
The hardened non-stick coated steel blades resist corrosion and cut cleanly through common cool-season grasses. The 4 cutting height stages from 0.47 inch to 1.65 inch lean toward the lower range, so this is a great pick if you like a tight cut.
The 15.75 inch cutting width is slightly narrower than most models in this guide, which means more passes for larger yards. The extra-large 54 inch wheels with their special tread pattern add some rolling resistance, so pushing this reel takes a bit more effort than smaller-wheeled models.
For owners of small European-style gardens or anyone who values long-term durability, the GARDENA Classic is worth the modest premium. The folding handle is a real space saver if you store your mower in a garage or shed.
Homeowners with small to mid-size European-style gardens, or anyone who wants the longest warranty in this category. It is also a great pick for low-cut warm-season lawns.
The narrow cutting width means more passes, and tall grass is not its friend. If you have a larger lawn, look at the 18-inch American Lawn Mower or Scotts options instead.
A reel mower uses a rotating cylinder of blades that shears grass against a fixed bedknife, producing a precise, scissor-like cut. Unlike rotary or gas mowers that rip grass with a high-speed blade, a reel mower leaves clean cuts that heal faster and reduce water loss.
The eco-friendly benefits start with the engine: there is none. No gas tank, no oil changes, no spark plugs, no exhaust. A reel mower that you push with your own muscle produces zero emissions and uses no fossil fuel. Even electric reel mowers draw a fraction of the energy a corded or battery mower uses.
According to the EPA, a typical gas push mower produces about 87 pounds of CO2 per year in emissions. A reel mower produces none. Over a 10-year ownership window, switching to a reel mower avoids roughly 870 pounds of CO2 – equivalent to a cross-country flight.
Noise is another overlooked benefit. A gas mower runs at 85 to 95 decibels; a reel mower runs at about 65 decibels. That is the difference between needing hearing protection and being able to hold a conversation while you mow.
Reel mowers work best on lawns under 5,000 square feet. Beyond that, the time and effort to push add up. For mid-size lawns between 2,500 and 5,000 square feet, choose an 18-inch or 20-inch model with a 5-blade reel.
For Bermuda and Zoysia lawns that thrive with a low cut, choose a 14-inch to 18-inch reel with 5 to 7 blades so you can mow down to a half inch. For Fescue, Kentucky Bluegrass, and Ryegrass, which prefer a taller cut, choose a 14-inch to 20-inch reel with 4 to 5 blades and a maximum cutting height of at least 2.5 inches.
More blades mean a finer cut, but also more resistance when pushing. A 4-blade reel is easier to push and works fine for cool-season grasses at standard heights. A 5-blade reel is the sweet spot for most homeowners. A 7-blade reel gives the finest cut for golf-style Bermuda or bentgrass lawns, but you will feel the resistance.
Cutting width affects how many passes you need. A 14-inch reel covers about 2,000 square feet per hour on a flat lawn. An 18-inch reel covers closer to 2,800 square feet. A 20-inch reel pushes the rate to 3,200 square feet.
Minimum cutting height matters for warm-season grass lovers. Most reel mowers go down to 0.5 inch, with some specialty models like the GARDENA Classic going to 0.47 inch. Maximum cutting height matters more for cool-season lawns and reaches up to 3 inches on the Scotts 2000-20S.
Look for a model with at least 4 height positions. More positions (like the 9 on the LawnMaster LMRM1801) give finer control as grass growth changes through the season.
The most common maintenance task is backlapping, a process where you apply sharpening compound and spin the reel backward to hone the blades against the bedknife. Most home users can do this every 2 to 3 years with a backlapping kit from the manufacturer.
For daily care, brush off clippings after each mow, lightly oil the reel shaft once per season, and store the mower indoors or under a cover. Hardware like handle bolts may need an annual snug-up.
Forum users consistently mention three pain points. First, manual reel mowers can be too light for uneven terrain, causing the wheels to ride high and leave uncut patches. Second, cheap reel mowers dull quickly, so investing in alloy steel or heat-treated blades pays off long term.
Third, jammed sticks and twigs are the number one cause of frustration. A quick pre-mow walk to clear debris saves significant hassle. Our team has not found a reel mower that completely resists jamming on twigs.
A manual reel mower is the most environmentally friendly lawn mower available. It produces zero emissions, requires no gas or electricity, and operates almost silently. The American Lawn Mower 1204-14 is our top pick for small lawns because it is lightweight, reliable, and backed by thousands of owner reviews.
The Great States 204-14 Hand Reel is our top pick for the best affordable reel mower. It has a 4.4 star rating, heat-treated alloy steel blades, and scissor-action cutting at a modest price. The LawnMaster LMRM1401 is even cheaper and works well for first-time reel mower buyers.
The main downsides of a reel mower are: it struggles with tall grass over 4 inches, it can jam on small sticks and twigs, it requires more physical effort than a powered mower, and cheap models may dull quickly. None of these are deal breakers for a maintained small lawn, but they matter if your yard is overgrown or full of debris.
A reel mower uses a rotating cylinder of blades that shear grass against a fixed bedknife with a scissor-like action. A rotary mower uses a single high-speed blade that chops or rips the grass. Reel mowers leave a cleaner cut that heals faster, while rotary mowers handle tall or thick grass better.
Most homeowners sharpen reel mower blades every 2 to 3 years with a backlapping kit. High-use lawns or lawns with sandy soil may need sharpening every 1 to 2 years. Heat-treated alloy steel blades stay sharp longer than standard steel.
Yes, a reel mower is worth the money for most small lawn owners. You save on gas, oil, spark plugs, and replacement engines. You also get a healthier cut and a quieter mow. Most reel mowers last 10+ years with simple annual maintenance, making them cheaper over time than a gas mower.
After testing ten popular models on Bermuda, Zoysia, Fescue, and Ryegass lawns, the American Lawn Mower 1204-14 remains the best reel mower for eco-friendly lawns. It combines a 4.3-star rating with a verified base of thousands of owner reviews, weighs just 19 pounds, and delivers the clean scissor-like cut that reel mowers are known for.
For homeowners on a tighter budget, the Great States 204-14 Hand Reel is our best value pick, and the LawnMaster LMRM1401 wins the budget slot. If you want the most precise cut for a golf-style lawn, go with the 7-blade Earthwise 1715-16EW.
Whichever reel mower you pick, you will be doing your lawn and your local air quality a favor. A reel mower uses zero fuel, makes almost no noise, and produces a healthier cut than any gas or electric rotary mower. Pair it with a smart sprinkler controller and an electric dethatcher, and your entire lawn care routine becomes emissions-free. For more sustainable home upgrades, take a look at our guide to organic coffee K-cups as well.
