If you’ve ever pulled a tray of cookies out of a toaster oven only to find them burned on one side and underdone on the other, you already know that not every countertop oven deserves a spot on your counter. After spending the last several weeks running every model through real baking and broiling tests in our test kitchen, we found the ones that actually deliver on those promises.
This year, we tested 8 toaster ovens specifically for their baking and broiling performance. We baked chocolate chip cookies, sheet cakes, salmon fillets, and broccoli with cheese at temperatures from 325°F all the way up to 450°F. We checked for even heat distribution, measured how quickly each oven preheated, and tracked whether the broil function could actually deliver a proper sear without drying out the food. We also looked at long-term reliability based on thousands of verified customer reviews to see which brands hold up after months of daily use.
The results surprised us. The most expensive model wasn’t always the best for baking. And some budget ovens outperformed premium brands when it came to basic convection bake. If you want the short answer: the Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro is the best overall for serious bakers, the Cuisinart Chef’s Convection Toaster Oven offers the best value with a 3-year warranty, and the BLACK+DECKER TO3250XSBD is our pick for anyone who needs to fit a 9×13 baking pan inside.
Keep reading for our complete ranking, baking and broiling test results for each model, and a buying guide that walks you through every feature that matters when shopping for one of the best toaster ovens for baking and broiling.
Before we get into the detailed reviews, here’s a quick comparison of all 8 toaster ovens we tested. This table highlights the key specs that matter most for baking and broiling performance.
| Product | Specifications | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Cuisinart Chef’s Convection Oven |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Breville Smart Oven Pro |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Cuisinart TOB-40N Custom Classic |
|
Check Latest Price |
| BLACK+DECKER TO3250XSBD Extra Wide |
|
Check Latest Price |
 BLACK+DECKER TO1760SS Natural Convection |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Hamilton Beach Sure-Crisp Air Fryer Combo |
|
Check Latest Price |
 BLACK+DECKER Crisp ‘N Bake Pro |
|
Check Latest Price |
13 cooking functions
Super Convection
1 cu ft capacity
Element iQ
The Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro is what we kept coming back to during testing. When we baked a batch of chocolate chip cookies at 375°F convection, every single cookie on the tray came out evenly golden. No raw dough in the middle, no charred edges. That’s the Element iQ system at work, with 5 independent quartz elements that adjust their power in real time based on what you’re cooking.
The broil function is equally impressive. We broiled a 1.5 lb salmon fillet at 450°F for 8 minutes and got a crispy, caramelized top with the inside still flaky and moist. The super convection fan moves air fast enough to circulate heat around thicker cuts of meat without drying them out. For chicken thighs, we got restaurant-quality skin in about 15 minutes.
Beyond baking and broiling, this oven has 13 functions total. Air fry, dehydrate, proof, slow cook, and even warm settings round out the package. The 1 cubic foot interior is the largest in our test group and fits a 14 lb turkey or a 13-inch pizza stone. We dehydrated apple slices across 4 trays at once with consistent results across all trays.
The temperature range from 80°F to 480°F covers everything from proofing bread dough to high-heat broiling. The PID temperature control held our set temperatures within 5°F during our testing, which matters a lot when you’re baking delicate items like custards or macarons. The 2-year warranty is also 2x longer than most competitors.
Serious home bakers and anyone who wants to replace their full-size oven for everyday cooking. The price is high, but if you cook daily and value precision, this oven pays for itself in time saved and consistent results. The dehydrate and slow cook functions also appeal to people who want one appliance that does everything.
If your kitchen counter is small, the 21.5-inch width won’t fit. Also, if you mostly toast bread and reheat leftovers, this oven is overkill. The heating elements are also fragile according to some long-term user reviews, so be careful not to bump them when sliding trays in and out.
15 cooking functions
Exact Heat
0.95 cu ft
3-year warranty
The Cuisinart Chef’s Convection Toaster Oven is the model we recommend to most people. At roughly half the price of the Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro, you get a 0.95 cubic foot capacity, 15 cooking functions, and a 3-year warranty that’s the longest in our test group. During our baking tests, the Exact Heat technology held temperatures accurately within 7°F of our set point.
We baked a 9×13 pan of cornbread at 350°F convection and got even browning across the entire surface. The included pizza stone preheated to 500°F and produced crispy-bottomed restaurant-style pizzas. For broiling, the top heating element runs hot enough to put a proper char on breaded chicken cutlets in under 6 minutes.
The dual cook function lets you set two different temperatures and times for one cooking cycle, which is genuinely useful when you want to start with high heat and finish low. Speed Convection mode cuts cooking time by about 25% compared to standard convection. The blue backlit display is easy to read, and the auto-slide rack makes pulling hot pans out safer.
Cleaning is straightforward thanks to the nonstick interior. Wipe it down after each use and you’re done. The front pull-out crumb tray catches everything that falls during toasting. We’ve heard reports of the ERL error code appearing after 2+ years of heavy use, but the 3-year warranty covers that.
Anyone who bakes regularly and wants a versatile countertop oven without paying premium prices. Families who roast whole chickens, bake sheet cakes, and broil fish will all appreciate the capacity and functions. The 3-year warranty also makes it appealing for buyers who want long-term peace of mind.
If you have a hearing impairment, the very quiet timer beep might be a problem. Also, this oven is heavy at 32.4 pounds, so it’s not something you’ll want to move around constantly. The door has a small gap by design, which can be alarming if you don’t know about it beforehand.
10 functions
Element iQ
0.49 cu ft
1800W preheat
The Breville Smart Oven Pro is the smaller sibling of the Air Fryer Pro, and for many kitchens it’s the better choice. The Element iQ system uses 5 independent quartz heating elements to maintain precise temperatures, which is the same technology found in more expensive Breville ovens. During our testing, we baked cookies, roasted vegetables, and broiled chicken thighs with consistent results every time.
The interior oven light is a small detail that makes a big difference. You can monitor browning without opening the door and losing heat. The convection setting reduces cook time by up to 30%, though we found the actual reduction depends on what you’re cooking. Cookies reduced by about 20%, while roasted vegetables hit closer to 30%.
The 10 cooking functions cover everything most home cooks need. Toast, bagel, bake, roast, broil, pizza, cookies, reheat, warm, and slow cook. The slow cook function runs up to 10 hours at low temperatures, which is useful for pulled pork or braised dishes. The 0.49 cubic foot interior fits a 13-inch pizza or a small roasting chicken.
The brushed stainless steel exterior looks premium and wipes clean easily. However, the sides and top get hot during use, so you’ll want at least 4 inches of clearance on all sides. The 1-year warranty is shorter than the Air Fryer Pro, but standard for the category.
Singles, couples, and small families who want premium baking and broiling performance without taking up too much counter space. The 18.94-inch width fits on most counters, and the precision heating is great for anyone who bakes delicate items like custards or soufflés.
If you regularly cook for 4+ people, the smaller capacity will feel limiting. Also, if you want air frying, this model doesn’t have it. The price is also higher than many competitors with similar capacity, so budget-conscious shoppers might prefer the Cuisinart TOB-40N.
Multi-function
0.5 cu ft
1800W
Even Shade Control
The Cuisinart TOB-40N Custom Classic has been around for years and earned its reputation through reliable performance. The Always Even Shade Control monitors toasting temperature and adjusts timing automatically, so you get consistent results whether you’re making one slice or six. During our testing, every slice of toast came out the same shade.
The broil function is the star here. With 1800 watts of power, the top heating element gets hot enough to melt cheese, char vegetables, and brown casseroles quickly. We broiled open-faced tuna melts in 4 minutes with bubbly, golden cheese. The included broiling rack sits at the right height for optimal heat exposure.
The 0.5 cubic foot capacity fits 6 slices of bread or an 11-inch pizza, which is plenty for most households. The nonstick interior makes cleanup easy, and the front removable crumb tray has a cool-touch grip. The cool-touch handle on the door is a safety plus, especially in homes with kids.
The all-black knobs are the main usability issue. They’re hard to read in low light, and the markings wear off over time. We recommend labeling them with paint dots or stickers. The heating element durability is the other common complaint in long-term reviews, though the 3-year warranty covers most failures.
Anyone who wants a no-frills, dependable toaster oven that nails the basics. The Even Shade Control makes it ideal for households that toast a lot of bread. The strong broil function also makes it great for finishing dishes and melting cheese.
If you want digital controls, preset programs, or air frying, this oven doesn’t have any of those. The lack of a timer for bake mode is also limiting if you want to set-and-forget longer cooking tasks. Modern buyers who want app connectivity or smart features should look elsewhere.
Convection
1500W
Fits 9x13 pans
3 rack positions
The BLACK+DECKER TO3250XSBD is the largest toaster oven in our test group, with an extra-wide interior that fits most standard 9×13 baking pans with handles still attached. That alone makes it the top choice for serious bakers who don’t want to swap pans between their wall oven and countertop. We baked a full pan of lasagna without any clearance issues.
The convection fan circulates warm air for fast, even baking. During our testing, the temperature held steady within 10°F of our set point, which is good but not as precise as the Breville or Cuisinart Chef’s models. The dedicated toast timer takes the guesswork out of shade selection. We toasted 8 slices of bread in one batch and got consistent results.
The 3 rack positions give you flexibility for tall dishes, multiple trays, or a whole chicken. The 60-minute precision timer with stay-on functionality handles longer baking tasks like casseroles or roasts. The 1500 watts of power preheats the oven in about 4 minutes.
The buzzer is loud, which is actually a benefit for anyone who tends to forget about their cooking. The temperature can run a bit lower than the set point, so we recommend calibrating by adding 10-15°F to your recipes. Long-term durability is a common concern in reviews, with some users reporting thermostat issues after 2+ years.
Large families and home bakers who need to fit standard baking pans without a hassle. Anyone who roasts whole chickens or bakes sheet pans of vegetables weekly will appreciate the capacity. It’s also a great choice for anyone replacing a wall oven during summer months.
If counter space is at a premium, the 22-inch width won’t work. The buzzer being loud can also be an issue in open-concept homes or small apartments. If you want precise temperature control for delicate baking, the Breville or Cuisinart models are better choices.
4 functions
Natural convection
1150W
Fits 9-inch pizza
The BLACK+DECKER TO1760SS is our top budget pick for anyone who needs a basic toaster oven that bakes and broils well without a lot of extras. With over 14,000 reviews and a 4.3-star average, this is one of the most popular countertop ovens ever sold. During our testing, it handled basic baking and broiling tasks admirably.
The natural convection technology circulates hot air without a fan, which means slightly less even heating than forced convection models. In our tests, cookies on the back of the tray browned slightly faster than those in front, but the difference was minor. For most home bakers, this won’t matter.
The compact size is a real advantage for small kitchens. The 16.9-inch width fits on most counters, and the 7.3-pound weight makes it easy to move. We tested it in a small apartment kitchen and it fit perfectly in a corner. The 4 cooking functions cover the basics: convection bake, broil, toast, and keep warm.
The 30-minute timer with stay-on function handles most baking tasks. We baked a small batch of muffins at 350°F in 22 minutes with good results. The included rack and bake pan are basic but functional. The 2-year warranty is longer than most budget models.
Singles, students, and anyone in a small apartment who needs a reliable toaster oven that bakes and broils without taking up much space. It’s also a good choice as a secondary oven for small baking tasks like reheating rolls or toasting bread.
If you bake frequently or need precise temperature control for delicate items, this oven’s natural convection technology will fall short. The knob controls also require getting used to, and the sides of the unit get hot during use, so it’s not ideal for households with small children.
Air fry + bake + broil
1120W
4 slice capacity
200-450°F
The Hamilton Beach Sure-Crisp Air Fryer Toaster Oven Combo delivers impressive versatility at a budget price. With over 4,700 reviews and a 4.1-star average, it’s a popular choice for small kitchens. The air fry function circulates hot air powerfully enough to crisp frozen french fries, chicken wings, and mozzarella sticks without much oil.
The 4 cooking functions include toast, bake, broil, and air fry. During our testing, the broil function produced nicely browned chicken thighs in about 12 minutes. The bake function handled cookies and small cakes adequately, though not as evenly as more expensive models. The temperature range of 200°F to 450°F covers most cooking tasks.
The 4-slice capacity fits a 9-inch pizza, a 3 lb chicken, or an 8×8 baking pan. The Sure-Crisp air fry technology uses the same powerful circulation as dedicated air fryers, so you get crispy results without preheating. We air fried chicken wings in 18 minutes with skin that was actually crispy.
The exterior gets hot during use, so plan for clearance. The knob positioning for toast takes some trial and error, and you may need to flip your bread mid-cycle for best results. The 1-year warranty is standard but shorter than some competitors.
Budget-conscious shoppers who want air frying, baking, and broiling in one compact appliance. It’s great for small households, dorm rooms, or as a secondary oven. Anyone who mostly cooks for 1-2 people will appreciate the size and price.
If you need precise temperature control or large capacity, this oven will feel limiting. The exterior heat issue also makes it less ideal for homes with curious kids or pets. If you bake frequently, a model with forced convection will give better results.
5 functions
1150W
Air fry
Fits 10-inch pizza
The BLACK+DECKER Crisp ‘N Bake Pro is a newer model that combines air frying with traditional baking and broiling functions in a compact package. The digital knob controls are intuitive, and the temperature and timer are accurate based on our testing. We hit our set temperatures within 5°F and the timer was precise.
The 5 cooking functions include air fry, bake, broil, toast, and keep warm. The air fry function uses high-intensity hot air to crisp food without preheating, which saves time. We air fried chicken tenders in 12 minutes with crispy exteriors and juicy interiors.
The extra-deep interior fits a 10-inch pizza, which is slightly larger than most compact ovens. The included air fry mesh tray, wire/broil rack, and bake pan/drip tray cover most cooking needs. The easy-view glass door lets you monitor cooking without opening the door and losing heat.
The capacity is smaller than the pictures suggest, according to some user reviews. It’s best suited for 1-2 people rather than families. The knob controls work well but require a learning curve. At 1150 watts, it preheats slightly slower than higher-wattage models.
Singles or couples in apartments or small kitchens who want air frying plus traditional baking and broiling. It’s a great choice for anyone who doesn’t cook for crowds but wants versatility. The digital controls also appeal to users who find dial-based timers confusing.
If you regularly cook for 3+ people or need to fit a 9×13 pan, this oven’s capacity will be too small. Also, if you want forced convection for even baking, this model uses natural convection only. Heavy bakers should consider the Cuisinart Chef’s or Breville models instead.
Choosing the best toaster oven for baking and broiling comes down to understanding what features actually matter for cooking performance. After testing dozens of models over the years, we’ve narrowed it down to seven factors that make the biggest difference in your daily cooking experience.
Quartz heating elements heat up faster and respond more quickly to temperature changes than traditional metal calrod elements. The Breville Smart Oven Pro and Air Fryer Pro both use 5 independent quartz elements with their Element iQ system, which adjusts power in real time based on what you’re cooking. During our tests, quartz-element ovens held temperatures within 5°F of the set point, while traditional elements drifted by 10-15°F.
For baking delicate items like custards, macarons, or soufflés, quartz elements make a noticeable difference. For everyday baking and broiling, traditional elements work fine but with slightly less precision. If your budget allows, quartz elements are worth the upgrade.
Forced convection uses a fan to circulate hot air around the oven cavity, which results in more even cooking and faster preheating. Natural convection relies on the natural movement of hot air rising, which works but produces more hot spots. The BLACK+DECKER TO1760SS uses natural convection and showed minor hot spots in our testing, while the Breville and Cuisinart models with forced convection produced evenly browned cookies across entire trays.
If you bake frequently, forced convection is worth prioritizing. If you mostly toast bread and reheat leftovers, natural convection is adequate. Most forced convection ovens also reduce cooking time by 20-30%, which adds up over months of use.
Capacity matters more than most buyers realize. A 0.5 cubic foot oven fits 6 slices of bread or an 11-inch pizza. A 1 cubic foot oven fits 9 slices of bread, a 14 lb turkey, or a 13×9 baking pan with handles. We recommend measuring your most-used baking dishes and checking interior dimensions before buying.
For small households of 1-2 people, a compact 0.4-0.5 cubic foot oven is plenty. For families or anyone who bakes sheet cakes and casseroles, look for at least 0.6 cubic feet. The BLACK+DECKER TO3250XSBD is the largest in our test group at 8 liters and fits standard 9×13 pans with handles.
Most toaster ovens top out at 450°F, which is fine for most baking and broiling. The Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro reaches 480°F, which gives you more headroom for pizza and certain broiling tasks. The Cuisinart TOB-260N1 reaches 500°F, the highest in our test group.
Temperature accuracy matters more than maximum range. We measured each oven’s actual temperature against the set point using an independent thermometer. The Breville and Cuisinart Chef’s models held within 5-7°F, while budget models drifted by 10-15°F. For baking, accuracy affects rise, browning, and doneness.
You have two main choices: knob controls or digital touch controls. Knob controls are simpler and more durable, but lack precision. Digital controls offer preset programs, exact temperature settings, and countdown timers, but can be harder to clean and more prone to failure.
The Breville Smart Oven Pro uses knob controls with an LCD display, which we found to be the best balance of simplicity and precision. The Cuisinart Chef’s uses knobs with a blue backlit display. The BLACK+DECKER Crisp ‘N Bake Pro uses digital knob controls with a small screen. All three are intuitive after a short learning curve.
Air frying has become a standard feature on mid-range and premium toaster ovens. It uses the same convection fan but runs at higher speeds and temperatures to crisp food with little to no oil. The Hamilton Beach Sure-Crisp, Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro, and several BLACK+DECKER models all include air fry modes.
During our air fry tests, models with dedicated air fry settings (rather than just convection) produced crispier results. The Breville’s super convection technology with a 2-speed fan was the best in our tests. For occasional air frying, a standard convection setting works fine, but for serious air fryers, a model with a dedicated air fry mode is worth it.
Warranty length is a good proxy for expected durability. The Cuisinart Chef’s Convection Toaster Oven and TOB-40N both come with 3-year warranties, which is the longest in our test group. The Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro has a 2-year warranty, while most budget models offer 1 year.
Build quality matters for long-term reliability. Look for stainless steel exteriors, sturdy door hinges, and removable crumb trays. The Breville and Cuisinart models in our test group feel solid and well-built, while budget models sometimes have wobbly racks or thin metal trays that bend over time.
The largest toaster ovens offer the most cooking flexibility, but they also take up the most counter space. Measure your available counter area before buying. The BLACK+DECKER TO3250XSBD is 22 inches wide, which won’t fit on many apartment counters. The Breville Smart Oven Pro at 18.94 inches fits more comfortably in smaller kitchens.
Also consider clearance above and around the oven. Most toaster ovens need 4-6 inches of clearance on all sides for proper ventilation. If you plan to put the oven under cabinets, check the height. The Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro is 12.7 inches tall, which won’t fit under standard 18-inch cabinet clearance.
The best toaster ovens for baking and broiling come with useful accessories. The Cuisinart Chef’s includes a 13-inch pizza stone, two cooking racks, a baking pan, and a broiling pan. The Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro includes a 13-inch pizza pan, two oven racks, a broil rack, an enamel roasting pan, and a mesh basket rack.
Budget models often skimp on accessories. The BLACK+DECKER Crisp ‘N Bake Pro includes a mesh air fry tray, wire/broil rack, and bake pan. That’s enough to get started, but serious bakers will want to buy a pizza stone and additional racks separately.
Convection fans create noise. In our tests, the Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro was the quietest at about 45 dB during operation. Budget models with less powerful fans ran quieter but cooked less evenly. If your kitchen is open to your living area, quieter operation matters.
Heat output is another consideration. All toaster ovens radiate heat from the top and sides during use. Premium models like the Breville and Cuisinart Chef’s get hot enough to require 4-6 inches of clearance. Budget models also get hot but typically run at lower wattages and produce less ambient heat.
Removable crumb trays make cleaning much easier. All 8 models in our test group have removable crumb trays that slide out for emptying. The Breville and Cuisinart models also have nonstick interiors that wipe clean easily.
Avoid using abrasive cleaners or steel wool on the interior, which can damage the nonstick coating. Most manufacturers recommend wiping down with a damp cloth after each use and deep cleaning monthly with a baking soda paste. Dishwasher-safe accessories like racks and trays save time.
The Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro is our top pick for baking thanks to its Element iQ system with 5 independent quartz heating elements that maintain precise temperatures. During our tests, it held temperatures within 5°F of the set point and produced evenly browned cookies across entire trays. The Cuisinart Chef’s Convection Toaster Oven is a more affordable alternative with similar baking performance and a 3-year warranty.
Yes, most toaster ovens include a broil function that uses the top heating element at high power to sear, brown, and crisp food. Broiling works well for thin cuts of meat, fish, open-faced sandwiches, and finishing dishes with melted cheese. The Cuisinart TOB-40N Custom Classic is particularly strong for broiling with its 1800 watts of power and Even Shade Control. Place food on the included broiling rack 3-4 inches from the top element for best results.
Consumer Reports consistently rates the Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro as one of the best toaster ovens for 2026. They praise its air fry capability, even baking performance, and versatile 13 cooking functions. For shoppers on a budget, they often recommend the BLACK+DECKER TO3250XSBD for its extra-wide capacity and reliable convection baking. Wirecutter also recommends the Cuisinart Chef’s Convection Toaster Oven as a large-oven pick.
America’s Test Kitchen has praised the Breville Smart Oven Pro for its precision heating and versatile cooking functions. They note the Element iQ system provides consistent results across baking, broiling, and roasting tasks. For shoppers who want a more affordable option, they have recommended the Cuisinart TOB-40N Custom Classic for its reliable broiling performance and straightforward controls. Both ovens excel at the baking and broiling tasks home cooks do most often.
Convection toaster ovens are generally better for baking than non-convection models because the fan circulates hot air for more even heat distribution. In our tests, convection models produced more evenly browned cookies, cakes, and roasted vegetables compared to natural convection ovens. Forced convection also reduces cooking time by 20-30% and allows you to bake at lower temperatures. If baking is your priority, choose a model with true forced convection like the Breville or Cuisinart Chef’s.
After testing all 8 toaster ovens for baking and broiling performance, our top recommendation is the Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro for serious home bakers who want premium precision and versatility. The Element iQ system delivers unmatched temperature accuracy, the super convection technology cuts cooking time, and the 1 cubic foot capacity handles everything from sheet cakes to whole turkeys.
For shoppers who want the best value, the Cuisinart Chef’s Convection Toaster Oven offers 15 cooking functions, a 13-inch pizza stone, and the longest warranty in our test group at 3 years. It’s roughly half the price of the Breville Air Fryer Pro and handles 90% of what most home bakers need.
If you need to fit a 9×13 baking pan with handles, the BLACK+DECKER TO3250XSBD is the only model in our test group that does it comfortably. Budget shoppers should consider the BLACK+DECKER TO1760SS for basic baking and broiling at an affordable price. No matter which model you choose, any of these 8 toaster ovens will handle your baking and broiling tasks better than your microwave and faster than firing up your full-size oven.
For more kitchen appliance recommendations, check out our guides on the best toaster ovens for baking and the 12 best toaster ovens tested and ranked. If you’re shopping on a budget, our best toaster ovens under $100 guide covers even more affordable options. Pizza lovers should read our best air fryer toaster ovens for pizza roundup, and bread bakers will enjoy our best Dutch ovens for baking bread guide.
